Sanchin "step offs"

From: raul jasso
Sent: Tuesday, May 08, 2007 3:15 AM
To: gmattson@uechi-ryu.com
Subject: Kaneis' SanChin

Hello Mr.Mattson,

I'm a big fan of your writings, especially 'The Way of Karate-Do', I have a question that perhaps you would be kind enough to answer: recently I came across an old film of Master Kanei Uechi, practicing 'sanchin' (it's on YouTube), in it he pivots right for the first circular block series, then 180 left, and finally center to end the excercise. My question is whether the Kata can be performed arbitrarily regardless of the sequence of right,left,center? And would it still produce the same training effect? Please excuse my ignorance.

Thank You
Hi Raul:

Usually, you step in the direction of the forward foot. However, the teacher can direct you (raising arm in direction where he/she wants you to move) in either direction.

Best,

George Mattson